Tool marks on an aluminium block: Ideal Mode against Feedback Mode

The part
A 70 × 50 × 50 mm block of Al6061-T6, a common heat-treated aluminium alloy, and the four NC programs of HiNC's demonstration project (named DemoStandardPath): a slot 40 mm long and 15 mm wide, a round slot around a Ø10 boss (10 mm diameter; a round post left standing in it), both 5 mm deep, a side face milled along one edge, and a sloped band along the opposite edge. In February 2019 the same tool paths cut a block in a cutting experiment made with a partner, and photos of that block show tool marks.
Tool
One end mill for all four programs: Ø12 mm, three flutes (cutting edges), its bottom corners rounded to a 0.5 mm radius, sticking out 28 mm from a plain cylindrical holder (the part that grips the tool and fits into the spindle) drawn in the project.
Data
No public source data: the demonstration project and the files of the experiment are not published. This page shows HiNC's results and photos of the machined block only.

The question

HiNC, from Tech Coordinate, the company behind this website, is machining simulation software: it runs an NC program on a model of the machine, cuts the part on screen and reports the cutting forces, the machining time, collisions and how far the result is from the design. Looked at in thousandths of a millimetre, a milled floor is not flat: the cutting force bends the tool, and the bend leaves marks. The photos of the block show arcs on the slot's floor and a straight mark on one of its walls. Can HiNC show such marks, and where they fall, before the part is cut?

HiNC computes a cut in one of two modes (Ideal Mode and Feedback Mode). Ideal Mode takes the tool as rigid: it cuts exactly where the program puts it, so the shape cut is the program's shape. Feedback Mode works out from the cutting force how far the tool bends, its deflection, and builds that bend into the shape it cuts. An AI agent, an AI program that carries out a whole job by itself, played the four programs once in each mode, at a machining resolution of 0.03125 mm (HiNC builds the block from small cubes, and this is the edge of the smallest; machining resolution) and one step per spindle revolution (a step is HiNC's unit of calculation). It compared each result with the design part, the 3D model of the finished block, using HiNC's geometry difference, which colours every spot by how far it lies from a reference shape, and read it at four visual radii, the difference at which the colour turns full blue or full red: 1, 0.1, 0.01 and 0.001 mm. For the walls it also used the shape Ideal Mode cut as the reference, which leaves only the difference between the two modes. Positions below are the program's X and Y in mm: the block spans X 2–72 and Y 0–50, the long slot X 15–55 and Y 32.5–47.5.

The block in HiNC seen at a slant from above after the four programs in Ideal Mode, the tool and its cylindrical holder parked above one corner; the slot floors orange, smooth blue and green bands around the start of each cut
Ideal Mode: the block after the four programs, the tool parked above it. Each cut face is coloured by the spindle torque (the twisting load the cut puts on the spindle) of the step that cut it last, from blue at 0 to red at 1.8 N·m, the bar printed below; the white top face and the grey sides are where these programs do not cut, and the dark blue around the block is the screen's background. The wide grey cylinder is the holder; the tool sticks out 28 mm below it, and the thin cylinder on top is the upper end of the same tool. The green ring marks where a holder with built-in sensors would take its readings; this case has no such measurement. The machine is hidden.
The same view and colouring in Feedback Mode: the tool and holder above the block, the long slot's floor broken into orange, green and blue patches
Feedback Mode, same view and colours. The long slot's floor breaks into wedge-shaped patches, and so does the round slot's near the front: each spot shows the step that cut it last, and in Feedback Mode the back half of the tool's bottom cuts again the floor its front half has just cut, so the spot takes the later step's value.

Ideal Mode against Feedback Mode

The long slot from above, compared with the design at 0.001 mm: above in Ideal Mode the floor all green; below in Feedback Mode the floor yellow to orange-red with crossing arcs, a ring around the middle and a band along the slot
The long slot from above (+X to the right, +Y up), compared with the design part at a visual radius of 0.001 mm: above Ideal Mode, below Feedback Mode. The colours follow the bar under the picture: green, no difference; blue, material left compared with the reference, full blue at +0.001 mm (1 µm); cyan, half of that; yellow to red, cut deeper than the reference, full red at −0.001 mm. In Ideal Mode the floor is green: it lies exactly at the programmed depth. In Feedback Mode it lies 0.01 to 0.90 µm deeper: arcs drawn by the edge of the tool's flat bottom, arcs and thin rings around the start hole in the middle (where the tool spiralled down to depth), and the boundary between the slot's two lanes (the 15 mm slot is cut along two lines 3 mm apart). The bright green around the slot is the top face; the blue ring along its edge is the 0.5 mm rounded corner the tool leaves at the foot of the walls, where the design has a sharp corner; the white glow near the lower corners is a reflection of the lighting. The small chequered patch near the start hole's centre in Feedback Mode is in the simulation's data; its cause was not looked into.
Four views of the long slot from above in Feedback Mode at visual radii of 1, 0.1, 0.01 and 0.001 mm: green at 1 mm, a blue edge ring from 0.1 mm, a faint yellow-green floor at 0.01 mm, the marks at 0.001 mm
The same Feedback Mode view at four visual radii, each with its own colour bar: top left 1 mm, top right 0.1 mm, bottom left 0.01 mm, bottom right 0.001 mm. At 1 mm the whole slot is green: no section of the tool path is missing. From 0.1 mm the rounded foot of the walls turns blue. At 0.01 mm the floor is only faintly yellow-green, since 0.9 µm is 9 % of the scale. At 0.001 mm the marks show. At 1 and 0.1 mm Ideal Mode looks the same as Feedback Mode.
An animation of the long slot seen at a slant from the block's front, compared with the design, switching every second: in Ideal Mode the floor all green; in Feedback Mode the floor yellow to orange-red with arcs, the far wall turning from blue to green in the middle
An animated picture that switches every second, from the same camera, between Ideal Mode and Feedback Mode: the long slot seen at a slant from the block's front (the −Y side), looking down at about 56°, +X to the right, compared with the design at 0.001 mm, colours as above. The white box at the top left names the mode in Chinese and English and gives the visual radius; the dark blue band along the top is the screen's background. Ideal Mode: the floor and the top face around the slot are the same green, no difference from the design; the far wall and the end walls (the curved walls at the two ends of the slot) are dark green, close to no difference; the bright blue line along the foot of the walls is the 0.5 mm rounded corner. Feedback Mode: the floor is yellow to orange-red, and the edges of its arcs and patches are the marks; the far wall is blue on the left, material left compared with the design, turns green at about X 35.5, the offset marked A further down, and grows bluer again towards +X; the end walls are bluish. The white glare in the middle of the far wall in both is a reflection of the lighting.
The round slot around the boss from above at 0.001 mm: left Ideal Mode, the floor green; right Feedback Mode, the floor orange near the boss, cyan near the outer wall, with arcs in front of the boss
The round slot from above, compared with the design at 0.001 mm, colours as above: left Ideal Mode, right Feedback Mode. The circle in the middle is the boss. In Ideal Mode the floor is green. In Feedback Mode it shades from orange by the boss through yellow and green to cyan near the outer wall: orange lies below the programmed depth, cyan above it, and the whole round slot's floor lies between 0.88 µm below and 0.34 µm above. The arcs in front of the boss lie where the circle starts and ends. The blue rings are the rounded feet of the boss and of the outer wall; the white glow at the lower sides is a reflection of the lighting.

Against the photos

Above, a photo of the machined slot with arcs on its floor; below, HiNC's Feedback Mode view of the slot from the same side, arcs and bands in yellow to orange-red on the floor
Above: the slot in a photo of the block, taken from its front and steeply from above, cropped. Two large arcs cross the floor around the start hole in the middle, smaller arcs lie in the right half, and a boundary runs between the two lanes. Below: Feedback Mode from about the same side, against the design at 0.001 mm, colours as above. The arcs around the start hole fall in the same place; where the photo has arcs in the right half, at about X 45 to 52, the simulation too has arcs drawn by the edge of the tool's flat bottom. The chequered patch at the start hole's centre is the one above. The far wall is blue on the left, turns green in the middle, at the offset marked A further down, and grows bluer again to the right; the white flare there is a reflection of the lighting.
Left, a photo of the whole block from above, its sloped band torn along the right edge; right, HiNC's Feedback Mode view of the block from above at 0.001 mm
Left: the whole block in a photo from above, turned so that +X points right: the long slot at the top, the round slot below, the sloped band along the right edge, torn along the outer edge of its back half. The large arcs on the top face come from flattening the top before these programs. Right: Feedback Mode from above, against the design at 0.001 mm: both slot floors carry marks; the sloped band, blue and red on the right, is far from the design, beyond the colour scale; the curved left edge is the side face seen from above; the dark blue around the block is the screen's background. The simulation does not tear material.
A photo of the machined block from above its front: arcs on the slot's floor, a line at the foot of the far wall, the sloped band along the right edge and the tearing outside it, each circled in red with a lowercase letter
The target block in a photo; every photo on this page shows this block. The camera is above the block's front, +X to the right and +Y up; the photo is turned upright and cropped. The red circles and lowercase letters are ours: a, arcs left on the slot's floor by the edge of the tool's flat bottom, two large crossing arcs in the middle matching the start hole and smaller arcs to the right; b, a double line at the foot of the far wall; d, the sloped band; e, the tearing along the band's outer edge. The narrow strip at the left edge is a neighbouring block, and the small grey patch beyond the tearing at the top right looks like another; the bottom edge in the middle is the top of the round slot's outer wall, and the dark brown above is the background.
The right face of the same block, photographed almost level: the top edge a ridge-shaped slope, smooth and bright on its front half on the left, torn into a saw-tooth edge on its back half on the right, each circled in red with a lowercase letter
The right face (the +X side) of the same block, photographed on the day it was cut, cropped. The camera is almost level, a little above; the block's front is on the left and its back on the right, and the round slot with its boss (left) and the long slot (right) show on the top face. The top edge is the ridge-shaped slope the sloped-band program cut (low at both ends, high in the middle): d, its front half, smooth and bright; e, its back half, its top edge torn into a saw tooth. The red circles and letters are ours; the green vertical streaks on the right face are reflections of things nearby, and the grey, white and dark things around the block are the background.

The photos and the simulation are compared for where the marks are, not for their shape or depth, for the reasons in the problem "What a photograph can be compared on" below; the places are matched by eye, without correcting the photos' perspective.

The walls: A, B and C

HiNC's product page shows three places on this slot's walls, A, B and C, in a picture coloured by spindle torque. The tool cuts the slot in three straight passes (runs of the tool along a line) after spiralling down at its centre: first along Y 41.5 towards −X to X 21, then along Y 38.5 towards +X to X 49, then along Y 41.5 back to the centre. At each turn the tool's centre moves 3 mm along X 21 or X 49 to the next pass, and that is when the end walls are cut: two arcs of 6 mm radius with a short straight piece between them. The +Y long wall is cut by the first and third passes, the −Y one by the second only. Compared with the shape Ideal Mode cut, Feedback Mode leaves the long walls further into the slot by a median of 2.4 µm (the middle value: half the wall stands further in, half less), and marks all three places.

Four close views of the slot's walls in Feedback Mode against the Ideal Mode shape at 0.001 mm: A, a sharp offset from blue to green on the +Y wall; B, a vertical line in the middle of each end wall; C, a gradual change from blue to cyan on the −Y wall; each circled in red
Feedback Mode against the shape Ideal Mode cut, 0.001 mm; green, the same as Ideal Mode; blue, material left compared with it; yellow to orange, cut deeper than it. In each view, from the top: the top face (dark green band), the wall, the rounded foot (bright line) and the floor (yellow to orange: the Feedback Mode floor lies deeper than the Ideal Mode one); the dark blue strip at the top of A is the screen's background. Top left, A: the +Y wall seen from the slot's −Y side; blue on the left, 1.3 to 3.9 µm more material than Ideal Mode left, then a thin green line and a narrow blue strip, then green with cyan vertical streaks to the right. Between X 35.5 and 36 the material left drops from 3.9 µm to 0.01 µm, an offset near where the first pass, cutting across the tool's full 12 mm width, meets the third, whose width of cut (how wide a strip the tool cuts into sideways) is about 1.5 mm. Top right and bottom right, B: the −X and +X end walls, each with a vertical line in the middle and the two sides left by different amounts; the vertical line lies where the end of one pass, the turn between passes and the start of the next meet, and which two of them meet there was not measured piece by piece. Bottom left, C: the −Y wall seen from the +Y side (+X to the left), shading from blue to cyan-green with no sharp offset; around here the second pass's width of cut grows from about 1 mm to about 10 mm, and between X 35 and 36.5 the material left grows from about 1 µm to 3.2 µm, then falls back. The red circles and letters are ours.
Above, a photo of the slot from the front at a low angle, a red circle round a straight mark on the far wall; below, place A in HiNC, left in Ideal Mode all green, right in Feedback Mode with the offset from blue to green
Above: the slot in another photo, from the front at a low angle (about 30° up), cropped; the red circle marks the straight mark on the far wall, at about X 35. Below: place A in HiNC, the far wall seen from the −Y side looking down at about 28°, +X to the right, both against the shape Ideal Mode cut at 0.001 mm: left, Ideal Mode itself, all green, a check that the reference reads zero; right, Feedback Mode, with the offset, and below it the floor in yellow to orange, cut deeper than in Ideal Mode. Each, from the top: the screen's background (dark blue), the top face (dark green band), the wall, the rounded foot (bright green line) and the floor; colours follow the bar under the picture.

Coloured by each step's values

HiNC can also colour the part's surface by a value it computes for every step, as the product page's picture does with spindle torque. The two pictures below show the long slot from above (+X to the right, +Y up), captured before the geometry difference, whose colours would cover the steps' colours.

Two views of the long slot from above in Feedback Mode, above coloured by spindle torque, below by re-cut depth, the floor in both broken into wedge-shaped patches
Feedback Mode. Each spot is coloured by a value of the step that cut it last, blue for low and red for high. Above, the spindle torque, on a bar from 0 to 1.8 N·m. Below, the re-cut depth (a value HiNC computes for every step: how far the tool's deflection moves the outer edge of its bottom along its axis, which is how deep the back half of the bottom cuts again the floor the front half has cut), on a bar from 0 to 0.8 µm; it is a simplified reading of the marks the 0.001 mm geometry difference shows, one value for a whole step, so the walls take it too. The top of each bar is the largest step value of a trial play on a shortened copy of the slot program (1.74 N·m, 0.74 µm) rounded up. The white beyond the rim is the top face, which has no step values. The floor breaks into wedges because in Feedback Mode the back half of the tool's bottom cuts again the floor already cut, and the spot takes the later step's value.
The same two views of the long slot in Ideal Mode, coloured by spindle torque and by re-cut depth: smooth bands along the passes and round the start hole, the start hole itself a blue disc
The same layout and bars in Ideal Mode. The colours run in smooth bands, drawn the way the product page's picture is. The blue disc in the middle is the start hole's floor: spiralling down, each step cuts very little, and the torque is close to 0 (about 0.06 N·m, the median of those few thousand steps). The arcs on either side of the start hole are where the three passes start and end. The re-cut depth below is not zero: Ideal Mode computes every step's deflection and re-cut depth too (a median of about 0.4 µm on the three straight passes) but does not build the deflection into the shape it cuts, so its floor still lies at the programmed depth at every point. The white beyond the rim is again the top face.

Four of the problems it met

Which block is in the photos?

The experiment's photos show at least four blocks with both slots, in aluminium and in stainless steel, cut with the original programs or with an optimised set. Only the original programs cut the sloped band, and of the two blocks that have one, only the aluminium block is torn along it. The experiment's notes say the band was first cut with too large a width of cut and damaged the part. That tearing, in the photo of the right face above, identifies the block; HiNC does not simulate tearing, and the page does not claim it predicted it.

What a photograph can be compared on

The photos and the simulation are compared only for where the marks fall: the arcs around the start hole, and the straight mark on the far wall near X 35, near where two passes meet. Shape and depth are not compared, for three reasons: a photo cannot measure depths of a few µm; the places in the photos are worked out by eye from the slot's width, without correcting the perspective; and how far the tool bends depends on its stick-out (how far it reaches out of its holder) and its flute length (the length of the part that carries the cutting edges). The project sets a 28 mm stick-out and a 20 mm flute length; there is no record of the stick-out on the day of the experiment to check them against.

The walls need another reference

Against the design, the 0.5 mm rounded foot of every wall reads as material left far beyond the 0.001 mm scale, since the design's corner is sharp, and the side face and the sloped band differ from the design by more than 0.1 mm. To see the walls' marks clearly, the agent exported the shape Ideal Mode cut and used it as the reference for the Feedback Mode result: only what the bending adds is left. Ideal Mode against itself reads all green.

One step per revolution is enough here

HiNC can also take a step for each flute's cut, three per revolution with this tool. On a shortened copy of the slot program, Feedback Mode took three to four times as long that way, and the floor differed from the one-step-per-revolution play by −0.06 to +0.08 µm at 98 % of the points (at most 0.55 µm); at 0.001 mm the pictures matched except for slight differences in the arcs at the two ends. The full plays used one step per revolution.

The full record, the detailed version of this case on HiNC's documentation site, has more views and the numbers behind them.

The result

Both plays ran the four programs to the end, with no collision and no rapid move (the machine's fastest move, meant for the air) through material: 16,391 steps each, counting two short programs that only move the tool through the air to frame the views and park it. In Ideal Mode the floors of both slots lie exactly at the programmed depth at every point measured. In Feedback Mode the long slot's floor lies 0.01 to 0.90 µm below it (median 0.47 µm), and the round slot's from 0.88 µm below to 0.34 µm above (median 0.38 µm below); the marks show at a visual radius of 0.001 mm, only faintly at 0.01 mm, and not at 0.1 or 1 mm, where both modes look the same. On the walls Feedback Mode marks A, B and C. The arcs around the start hole and the straight mark on the far wall sit where the photos show them. The agent measured these heights on the shapes HiNC exported as STL files (the surface as small triangles), not off the colours, which agree with them. A play took 21.6 minutes in Ideal Mode and 27.5 minutes in Feedback Mode, about 1.27 times as long, on a 32-thread server (it runs 32 calculations at once) shared with other work, which can shift such times by tens of percent; the peak memory was about 7.8 to 7.9 GB in both modes.

Key numberWhat it is
16,391steps in each play, one per spindle revolution, at a machining resolution of 0.03125 mm: the four programs and two short ones that only move the tool through the air to frame the views and park it
0 µmIdeal Mode: how far the floors of both slots lie below the programmed depth, at every point measured
0.01–0.90 µmFeedback Mode: how far the long slot's floor lies below the programmed depth (median 0.47 µm)
0.88 µm below to 0.34 µm aboveFeedback Mode: the round slot's floor against the programmed depth (median 0.38 µm below), higher near the outer wall
0.001 mmthe visual radius at which the marks show; at 0.01 mm they are faint, at 0.1 and 1 mm the two modes look the same
3.9 µmthe offset at A in the +Y wall, between X 35.5 and 36 mm, Feedback Mode against the shape Ideal Mode cut
2.4 µmmedian of how much further into the slot Feedback Mode leaves the long slot's two long walls than Ideal Mode
5.5 mmradius of the arcs the tool's edge leaves on the floor: the tool's 6 mm radius less its 0.5 mm corner
21.6 · 27.5 minone play in Ideal Mode and in Feedback Mode on a shared 32-thread server, about 1.27 times as long; peak memory about 7.8–7.9 GB

What it brought

Read the full case record: tool marks on an aluminium block

All Showcase cases