Table of Contents

Reading the Load Leaves

A step's load is how hard its cut works the cutter and the spindle: the cutting force HiNC simulates on the step, whose largest value over the cutter's rotation is Max Absolute Force, and what that force does — the stress in the cutter, the torque and the power asked of the spindle, and the heat in the spindle and at the cutting edge. Machining State judges a load not by the force itself, since the same force loads a slimmer cutter or a longer stick-out harder, but by five ratios on which 100 % is the limit: the cutter's Stress Ratio; the spindle's Max Spindle Torque Ratio, Max Spindle Power Ratio and Spindle Working Temperature Ratio against the spindle capability; and the Thermal Stress Ratio at the cutting edge. Beside them stand the cutter's Breakage Probability, worked out from the stress ratio, and Spindle Speed Deviation, how far the spindle slows under the cut, neither of them a ratio to a limit. A cut whose stress ratio or spindle ratios have no value — the physics did not run on it, for one — is Load not evaluated unless one of them that has a value is over its limit: an unknown load, never a safe one. Without a spindle capability, a cut is Load not evaluated only where its stress ratio has no value. The load targets NC optimization holds the feed to are drawn from them: a Preferred Force, a cutting force in newtons (The Target Cutting Force (Preferred Force)), safety factors on the stress ratio, the thermal stress ratio and the two spindle ratios (The optimizer, as a step), and any custom target a script sets.

The rest of this page covers how Machining State reads a cut's load, and where that reading stops. Where the two built-in trees sit, what their other leaves are and how a copy is made are on Engineering View Coloring.

  • Stress overload and High breakage probability read the cutter, the next four leaves the spindle. The stress ratio sets the stress at the cutter's critical section against its material's stress limit (Evaluating Process Machinability): under 100 % the cut is safe by HiNC's reading, and at 100 % or more the machining is bad, though not necessarily failed: such a cut in a program already in production, or in a process the customer has already accepted, does not by itself mean the simulation is wrong, unless High breakage probability reads over 10 % there and the cutter keeps running unbroken, which puts HiNC's reading there in doubt (Bad Machining, Not Necessarily Failed Machining); the readings the engine is known to get wrong are under Known limits. A step whose stress ratio is 100 % or more is a Stress overload at once, however short, and the value in its lane is the ratio. A spindle over its torque or power limit slows down, each revolution then taking a thicker chip, and HiNC simulates on every step how far it has slowed (the next item). A step over the torque limit is a Spindle torque overload, one over the power limit a Spindle power overload, for as many steps as the spindle stays above its end point, the speed at which the cutter breaks or the chip has no room. Past the first step of the overload, a step whose spindle has slowed to that end point is a Spindle torque sustained overload or a Spindle power sustained overload.
  • The spindle speed under load is simulated, and read as the step's mean. On every step HiNC works out how fast the spindle turns under the cut, from the spindle capability: the shortest-duration torque curve limits the motor torque at every tool angle, the shortest-duration power curve the mean power over the step, one revolution by default, and both are compared with the cut itself, so the energy efficiency is not read. A steady cut slows from the programmed speed once the max spindle torque ratio or the max spindle power ratio is over 100 %. An interrupted cut whose peak in a revolution exceeds the torque curve dips at every tooth and cuts deeper the next step — the next revolution, with one revolution a step —, with a power ratio that can stay under 100 %. The speed recovers on an air cut, a rapid and a dwell, and starts again from the programmed speed where the programmed speed, the direction of rotation or the tool changes. A rapid step is taken as a step without load even where it cuts the stock: its deviation reads the recovery, so such a step can be a Spindle torque overload whose lane shows about 0 % beside a torque ratio far over 100 %. What reports a rapid that cuts is Rapid cut, with its warning (Reading Rapid cut). Spindle Speed Under Load (SpindleSpeedUnderLoad_rpm) is the step's mean speed: the angle the spindle turned in the step over the angle it turns at the programmed speed, times the programmed speed. The dip inside a tooth of an interrupted cut is in it as a mean, not as its lowest instant; the mean is the speed that sets the next step's feed per tooth, the next revolution's where a step is one revolution. Spindle Speed Deviation (SpindleSpeedDeviation_percent) says how much slower than programmed that is, in percent: 0 % at the programmed speed, 20 % where the next step's feed per tooth — the next revolution's, with one revolution a step — is 1.25 times the programmed one under a feed per minute, 99 % at the simulation's floor. The speed is an estimate alone: HiNC does not feed it back into the cutting force, so a step's force, its spindle ratios and its stress ratio stay the values at the programmed speed (Known limits). A step the physics did not run on shows no speed and no deviation of its own. Where the spindle turns on such a step, the simulation takes it as a step without load, over which the speed recovers as over an air cut, even where the step did cut; where the spindle does not turn, no speed is kept, and the next step on which it turns starts from the programmed speed.
  • High breakage probability is a second line over Stress overload's steps. On a step whose stress ratio is 100 % or more, each material at its own stress limit, two lanes show together: the value in Stress overload's lane is the stress ratio, and the value in the lane right under it, High breakage probability, is the breakage probability (Breakage Probability), each lane with its grey bar. Under 100 % neither lane has a bar or a line. It is one set of steps with two lines and two meanings: how far over the limit, and how likely the cutter is to break there. The breakage probability's own threshold is what the material reads at its own stress limit, so no single number stands for it: that reading differs by material — about 0.0088 % on the shipped WC-Co6-800nm, about 0.29 % on a material that gives a tensile strength alone — which the line shows and the stress ratio does not; the legend prints the first as <0.01%.
  • One step, one state. Such a step stays a Stress overload: Step Properties prints 4 · Stress overload, the 3D view paints it in Stress overload's colour, and the step file's MachiningState column holds 4, never 16. High breakage probability shows its bar and its line and no state of its own: the column's tint stays Stress overload's, the legend's row of the tree names Stress overload and leaves it out, and its swatch has Stress overload's colour because the 3D view has no second colour for those steps. In the Colors dropdown the two rows stand one under the other. Each row's share divides by the drawn time, those steps counted once, so the two rows read the same when every one of those steps has a probability, and the column adds up to more than 100 % by the second row's share. A step whose probability cannot be worked out — its material gives a yield strength alone, for example — still lights Stress overload and has no line: the row of High breakage probability counts only the steps with a value, and reads — when none has one.
  • The two sustained overloads read the step's place in its run and the spindle's speed, not the continuous rating. A run is the consecutive steps over the spindle's torque limit, or over its power limit. Spindle torque sustained overload takes a step past the first of a torque run — SpindleTorqueOverloadStepOrdinal, 1 on the run's first step and 2 on its second, above 1 — whose spindle has slowed to its end point: SpindleSlowdownEndpointRatio at 1 or more. The one step of margin allows for HiNC's own computing error. Spindle power sustained overload asks the same of a power run, SpindlePowerOverloadStepOrdinal, with the spindle at or past its end point, whatever the step's place in a torque run. It takes a step over the power limit alone — its torque run has ended while its power run goes on, or its cut never passed the torque limit —, and the first step of a torque run that begins inside such a power run; a step past the first of a torque run is Spindle torque sustained overload's already: there the power's sustained leaf holds beside it, and the chart bars both. Neither leaf has anything to do with the continuous (S1-rated) torque and power ratios, ContinueSpindleTorqueRatio and ContinueSpindlePowerRatio, which no leaf reads.
  • The end point is a share of the programmed speed. It is the largest of three: the step's stress ratio, since under a feed per minute the force and the stress grow as the spindle slows — a stress ratio of 80 % reaches 100 % at 80 % of the programmed speed —, and 90 % where the stress ratio has no value; the feed per tooth over a fifth of the cutter diameter, the room the flute has for the chip, left out where the step has no feed per tooth or no diameter; and 1 %, the simulation's floor. Spindle Slowdown Endpoint Ratio (SpindleSlowdownEndpointRatio) is that share over the step's mean speed as a share of the programmed speed, so it reads 1 or more once the spindle is at its end point, and 0 on a step that does not cut. On a step that cuts it reads NaN while the speed is not known, unless it is the rotor inertia that cannot be derived (Known limits). These conversions are how HiNC turns “the cutter breaks” and “the chip has no room” into a speed, not measured limits of a cutter.
  • The spindle's leaves name the cause. The torque ratio sets the peak torque of a revolution against the spindle's torque limit at the step's speed, the power ratio the power of the revolution against its power limit there. Each pair of leaves reads its own ratio and its own runs, so a step's lane says which limit it is over. Spindle torque overload shows the spindle speed deviation, how much the spindle has slowed on that step, and Spindle power overload shows the max spindle power ratio, how far the cut is over the power limit; the two sustained leaves show the spindle speed deviation, as Spindle torque overload does. The order is sustained before the plain overload, the torque before the power within each: a step in runs of both, or over both limits, takes the first leaf that holds, its other ratio and run still readable in Step Properties, and the chart bars the other leaves that hold on it beside that leaf. Every orange step bars the yellow leaf of the same cause too, since its ratio is over the limit. A step whose stress ratio is 100 % or more is a Stress overload already.
  • Which strength the stress ratio reads. It compares the stress at the cutter's critical section with one strength its material file gives, the stress limit: YieldStrength_MPa where the material gives one, the more conservative of the two strengths — a ductile steel such as AlloySteel42CrMo, the body of an insert-end cutter unless the cutter names another material, yields at 930 MPa — else TensileStrength_MPa. A carbide, a ceramic, a CBN or a coating has no yield point, and its file says so with <YieldStrength_MPa>NotDuctile</YieldStrength_MPa>, as every shipped cutter material does, the hardened high-speed steels included: its stress limit is its tensile strength. A material whose yield strength is merely not known has no such element and reads its tensile strength too. No ratio divides by FractureStrength_MPa, a carbide's transverse rupture strength or a high-speed steel's bending rupture strength: it is the bending strength the breakage probability reads.
  • The spindle revolutions are the run's. SpindleTorqueOverloadRevolutions counts a whole run of steps over the spindle's torque limit, SpindlePowerOverloadRevolutions one over its power limit, each run apart, and a step reads its run's count once the run closes — at a step at or below that limit or unknown, at a rapid, at the end of the play — and the count so far while it is open; a play stopped at a pace point leaves its last run open until the next play starts or a reset, a stop between blocks closes it (Step Field Reference). The revolutions are counted at the programmed speed, not at the speed under load, with the run's yellow steps among them. They are step properties alone, read in Step Properties and the Science view: no leaf's condition reads them, and no leaf shows them in its lane.
  • Each step is judged by itself. A step's place in its run is set when the run's first step is played, and a step is orange by its own mean speed against its own end point. So a run that closes turns none of its earlier steps orange, and inside one run a step can go back from orange to yellow, and to orange again, for these reasons: the load drops under what the two curves give at the speed of the moment, and the speed recovers above the end point; the step's own stress ratio is lower, so its end point is further down; the speed, having reached the simulation's floor, starts again from the programmed speed on a step whose cut the spindle carries at that speed; or the programmed speed changes inside the run, which does not close it, and the speed starts again from the new programmed speed. A torque run that begins inside a power run already orange keeps its first step orange: with the spindle still at its end point, that step is a Spindle power sustained overload, and Spindle torque sustained overload comes a step later, taking the next.
  • Spindle overheat needs the physics. The spindle's temperature evolves with the physics off as well, so the leaf also asks for the power ratio, which has a value only where the physics ran and the spindle capability gives limits at the step's speed: elsewhere an overheated spindle's cut is Load not evaluated. A play with no spindle capability to read against has no spindle temperature at all, and the leaf is left out of the tree with the other four spindle leaves (Without a spindle capability).
  • Load not evaluated is never read as safe. A cut lands there when one of the three ratios has no value: the physics was off or did not run on the step, the spindle capability gives no limits at the step's speed, or the cutter's stress ratio cannot be evaluated. A ratio that has a value and is over its limit still decides first: a stress ratio of 100 % or more is a Stress overload, a spindle ratio over 100 % one of the four spindle leaves — the thermal stress ratio does not: Thermal stress overload is tried after Load not evaluated, so such a cut shows as Load not evaluated and its thermal stress ratio is still readable in Step Properties. The notes say which cause applies (Reading the Notes), but for a speed without limits, which the play's warning Spindle-Limits--Unreadable names. A play with no spindle capability to read against is read otherwise: the tree has no spindle leaves, Load not evaluated takes only the cuts whose stress ratio has no value, and a cut whose stress ratio is under 100 % goes on to Thermal stress overload or Normal cutting — there Normal cutting says nothing of the spindle, which the spindle capability's note says once (Without a spindle capability).
  • Thermal stress overload is machining that loses points: a loss of tool life, not a breakage risk. The thermal stress ratio sets the thermal stress at the cutting edge against the flute material's stress limit (Thermal Plastic Deformation of Cutting Edge): at 100 % or more the edge deforms plastically and wears faster, while nothing breaks at once — a long-term reading, unlike the stress ratio. Kept under 100 %, the cutter lasts noticeably longer. The leaf comes after the other load leaves, so a cut that is also over a limit, or whose load has no value, shows as that leaf. Many ordinary cuts fall into it, and that is its usual look. An entry or an exit cut, whose thin chip tends to leave its heat in the edge, as a rule comes down less, though how much a case shows it depends on the edge temperatures the thermal model reaches; outside them such a cut can be optimized, usually by changing the spindle speed by hand, while HiNC's NC optimization holds the ratio only when Thermal Stress Safety Factor is set on the NC Optimization Config command's Force & Safety node (The optimizer, as a step), by the feed per tooth at the programmed spindle speed (Thermal Plastic Deformation of Cutting Edge). A cut that only grazes the stock tends to read higher with EnableEngagementAngleSweepingArc on, as by default, and so does a graze whose contact is narrower than its chip is thick, which can then read over 100 % (the same section). Whether such a graze touches the stock at all can differ between two plays (Contact on a grazing step). Where the physics did not evaluate the thermal stress — the physics off on the step, a tool that is not a milling cutter, a cutter whose Flute Profile does not agree with itself, a cutter without a flute material — the ratio reads 0 % and the leaf takes no step. A solid-end cutter without a flute material has no stress ratio either, so its cuts are Load not evaluated; an insert-end cutter without one is judged by the other leaves alone (Known limits).
  • Normal cutting takes every other cut, a thin chip or a graze included unless its thermal stress ratio makes it a Thermal stress overload: a cut that removes little now and then is normal, and no leaf warns of the little it removes.

Known limits

The load leaves take the engine's forces and ratios at their word, so where a reading is wrong or partial the colour is too. The limits are of a few kinds: the engine's known misreads on some cut shapes and one part setup, and a spindle ratio over its limit on a very short move; the spindle speed under load, a simulation on assumptions checked against no machine; cuts the physics did not compute and thermal stresses it did not evaluate, which no note explains; two inputs a project holds, a spindle capability nobody chose and an old copy of a cutter material; and what to expect from a tool change, a CSV program, a review, collision detection without a licence, a failed read, an earlier HiNC and the Science view's default colour ranges. Each is on Known Limits of the Load Leaves.

See Also